Group

Elden Ring is more than a game of swords and sorceries—it's a vast narrative web of characters whose destinies often hinge on subtle choices and rare Elden Ring items. While many items enhance combat or exploration, a special few can radically alter the fate of NPCs, unlocking storylines, alternate endings, or rare rewards. Understanding these items is key, especially for new players considering where to focus their effort—or when exploring Elden Ring items buy for beginners options to avoid missing out on critical story paths.

After several playthroughs, I've found that these seven items stand out not just for their utility, but for how they shape the stories of others. Here's what you need to know.

1. Stormhawk King (Nepheli Loux)Found in the Chapel of Anticipation, the Stormhawk King Spirit Ash isn't just a summon—it plays a critical role in Nepheli Loux's quest. Giving it to her restores her confidence and allows her to succeed as Lord of Limgrave if you also meet certain conditions. The first time I missed it, Nepheli’s story ended abruptly. On a second playthrough, I gave her the ash, and the difference was both emotional and rewarding.

2. Dung Eater Puppet (Seluvis Questline)As unsettling as it sounds, Seluvis allows you to turn the Dung Eater into a Spirit Ash puppet. If you follow this path, it locks out his main questline and alters his ending. This item essentially determines whether the Dung Eater becomes a feared invader or a grotesque summon under your control. It's a perfect example of how Elden Ring items reflect moral ambiguity.

3. Amber Starlight (Seluvis)Found in the Altus Plateau, this glowing fragment can be given to Seluvis in exchange for a potion that can influence other characters—specifically Ranni. If used, it ends her questline early, affecting your access to one of the game’s best endings. I tried this path once and immediately regretted losing Ranni’s deeper storyline. Still, it illustrates how one item can change the world.

4. Shabriri Grapes & Fingerprint Grape (Hyetta)Hyetta’s transformation into a Finger Maiden depends entirely on receiving three Shabriri Grapes and one Fingerprint Grape. As her perception changes with each gift, so too does her dialogue and eventual role. The first time I gave her all the grapes, I was struck by how dramatically her tone and fate shifted. It’s haunting, yet beautifully executed.

5. Mending Rune of the Fell Curse (Dung Eater)This item directly affects one of the game's alternate endings. Obtaining it requires progressing the Dung Eater’s quest, unlocking access to the so-called "bad" ending. Even if you don’t use it, simply acquiring it changes your dialogue options and choices at the endgame. It’s a must-have for players seeking a full narrative experience.

6. Gold Sewing Needle (Boc the Seamster)After helping Boc early in the game, giving him the Gold Sewing Needle lets him alter demigod armor. This not only enhances your fashion options but gives Boc a sense of purpose. I always make sure to complete this quest now—it’s one of Elden Ring’s most heartfelt moments, and it all hinges on a single gift.

7. Tonic of Forgetfulness (Tanith)Given to you by Rya (or Tanith depending on your path), this item can be used to erase Rya’s memories, preventing her from discovering the full horror of Volcano Manor. This is a tragic choice—it spares her pain, but at the cost of truth. I once used it to preserve her innocence, and though she remained safe, I always wondered what could’ve been if I let her learn the truth.

While the instinct might be to hoard or quickly use items for progression, some of the most impactful Elden Ring items are those tied to characters' fates. Whether you’re following a guide or exploring Elden Ring items buy for beginners to ensure you don’t miss anything vital, it’s worth knowing what items shape the stories around you.

From my experience, paying attention to how items affect NPCs made each playthrough more emotionally resonant. These aren't just tools—they're decisions, forks in the road, and sometimes the difference between hope and despair in the Lands Between.

What You Missed: 7 Ways to Safely Buy Elden Ring Runes Without Risks